tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2752759394489234151.post588102375225818183..comments2015-12-03T22:46:30.768-05:00Comments on Serial Scoop: 'The Young and the Restless': The Real Reason David Tom Was Replaced as Billy AbbottRoger Newcomb[email protected]Blogger3125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2752759394489234151.post-76847853743270802172014-07-09T18:36:21.660-04:002014-07-09T18:36:21.660-04:00David Tom WAS doing great. As I have said before,...David Tom WAS doing great. As I have said before, he was never going to be Billy Miller. But it was very comforting having a familiar face in the role. He had great chemistry with Melissa Claire Egan, is a great actor, and it's just a shame that it all came down to wanting someone to take his shirt off.Michael Goldberg http://www.blogger.com/profile/10147462564348483332[email protected]tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2752759394489234151.post-566450781631545152014-07-09T09:10:09.371-04:002014-07-09T09:10:09.371-04:00This kind of move has happened before (especially ...This kind of move has happened before (especially with kids we watch grow up that are suddenly replaced by an older hunky young adults) but with Y&R's current situation the recast just made me very sad about the state of the show. The storylines don't make me "feel" anything at the moment and this moves just reinforces the belief that the priorities for the show (aside from making a budget) are shallow and superficial ones, and NOT about telling compelling long-term stories. Meanwhile. B&B is doing just about everything right. There are lessons to be learned there but it's not clear whether anyone at Y&R, CBS or Sony think there's anything wrong with the show that a new hunk with a nice chest wouldn't fix. It's like they looked at the show, didn't notice there are no great stories, bad music or cheap looking sets, and said to themselves, "I think we're just about perfect, all we need to do is replace David Tom with a hunkier guy." We've seen this before with shows that eventually got canceled. Once it's clear to the audience that they care a lot more about a soap's integrity, history and quality than those running it, even the most diehard fans start to turn away.Roger Newcombhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/17605713149480918249[email protected]tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2752759394489234151.post-68814662181136116342014-07-08T18:44:11.920-04:002014-07-08T18:44:11.920-04:00Recasting just so Billy would be a hunk shows what...Recasting just so Billy would be a hunk shows what is wrong with YR. David Tom was doing great.UghhhConfessions and Critiques from a TV fanatic.http://www.blogger.com/profile/01877002470110729422[email protected]